Creamy Garlic Mushroom Pasta Recipe - Sip and Feast (2024)

Fragrant garlic, earthy mushrooms, silky ribbons of pappardelle; there isn’t a better combination of ingredients for an easy, quick,(and inexpensive) meal that will fill bellies, stick to ribs, and delight tastebuds. This creamy garlic mushroom pasta is perfect for those crazy weeknights when you just need an easy button and a glass of wine.

Editor’s Note:Originally Published November 28, 2018. Updated with full process shots, detailed YouTube Video, and expanded info.

This creamy garlic mushroom pasta may not follow a classic “Italian” recipe, however, it is a classic in our home and that’s good enough reason for us to share with you!

And besides, we are using classic Italian ingredients, like salty sheep’s milk Pecorino Romano, fresh garlic, and extra virgin olive oil.

If you’ve come to this page because you’ve got a hankering for some stick-to-your-ribs pasta, make sure to check out our short rib ragu, authentic pasta bolognese, and this creamy Italian sausage pasta.

All three dishes are made with pappardelle pasta (the same pasta used for this recipe).

Creamy garlic mushroom pasta step by step instructions

Each number corresponds to the numbered written steps below.

1. Clean any dirt off the mushrooms with a paper towel and slice like shown. Also, chop or slice the garlic and chop the parsley. Cook pasta to 1 minute less than package directions (Photo #1).
2. Saute the garlic in the olive oil on medium heat for 1 minute (Photo #2).

3. Add the mushrooms to the pan and turn heat to medium-high. Let the mushrooms release their water (Photo #3).
4. Keep sauteing for a few more minutes to get them nice and brown (Photo #4).
5. The mushrooms are now nice and brown. Before draining the pasta make sure to reserve 2 cups of pasta water. I ladle the 2 cups into a large coffee mug for this step (Photo #5).
6. Next, add the salt, pepper, and 1 cup of pasta water. Cook for 1 minute, then turn heat to low and add the cream and cheese and stir it all together (Photo #6).

7. The sauce will be smooth and creamy like shown in the picture (Photo #7).
8. Add the pasta to the sauce and thoroughly incorporate everything (Photo #8). Taste the sauce and if it needs more salt or pepper add it now. Add the parsley and stir it all together. If before plating the sauce thickens up too much on the pasta, use a little bit of the extra pasta water to thin it out.

So friends, seeing how easy this creamy mushroom pasta is to make, and knowing that it can be on your table quicker than your to-go order, go grab your ingredients and start cooking.

Oh, and pour yourself that glass of wine. A drier Riesling or a Chardonnay would pair perfectly and would certainly help to bring out the flavors in the dish.

What type of mushrooms to use?

Use whatever mushrooms you have available in your local grocery store.

We used white button mushrooms because they are the most widely available, and least expensive and we wanted to account for ingredient availability and cost with this particular recipe.

That’s not to say that other mushrooms wouldn’t be fantastic. Cremini, shiitake, large portobellos cut up into strips, chanterelle, and oyster mushrooms would all be great choices.

But again, for this dish, use what is easy, available, and budget-friendly.

How to correctly cook mushrooms?

Mushrooms are like sponges and have the ability to retain a lot of liquid.

Cooking them is quite simple as long as the heat is high enough in the pan to evaporate the water they release.

If they are sauteed too low they can boil out. When working with a lot of mushrooms like in this dish, the water can be a slight issue.

White mushrooms release a lot more water than the others mentioned above.

We suggest draining the water from the pan and turning the heat to high to get them nice and brown.

Mushrooms require no oil or butter to saute as they will release water and still brown after it all evaporates. The only olive oil these are cooked in is what was leftover from sautéing the garlic.

Cream or half and half?

We recommend using heavy cream because the sauce will never break. This can happen when using half and half. and the sauce will never break.

Interestingly enough, there are some pasta dishes that while extremely creamy in nature have no cream at all, such as the classic Roman pasta, Cacio e Pepe, which relies upon the combination of the pecorino and the starchy pasta water to form a velvety, creamy consistency.

For the purposes of this dish though, we use heavy cream.

Pecorino Romano substitute

Full disclosure – I love Pecorino Romano cheese. It is my favorite cheese. Use it if you can find it!

It is the cheese used in the classic Roman pastas, and I put it on almost everything, from Spaghetti Amatriciana to a hearty bowl of Pasta fa*gioli.

Parmesan cheese also works for this dish.

Pecorino really is quite salty and we’ve accounted for that in the recipe by using only 1 tsp of salt. So make sure to test the sauce at the end if you opt to use a less salty cheese like parmesan or a different cheese.

More delicious mushroom recipes

• Pasta alla Norcina – Sausage, diced mushrooms, cream, and white wine with a touch of nutmeg.
• Beef Stroganoff – Seared steak and mushrooms in a tangy cream sauce with buttery egg noodles.
• Spicy creamy mushroom pasta – Calabrian chili paste, tomato, cream, pasta, and sauteed mushrooms.
• Mushroom risotto – Arborio rice, mushrooms, shallots, and Parmigiano Reggiano.
• Easy sauteed mushrooms – Garlic, parsley, olive oil, and a pinch of hot red pepper flakes.
• Mushroom brandy cream sauce pasta – Creamy brandy sauce with seared mushrooms over linguine.

This recipe was originally published on November 28, 2018. It was completely updated on October 27, 2020.